Chapter 21
Global Communism
- jokes from Soviet-era highlight hypocrisy of the communist system
- reflect growing disbelief that the communist system could deliver promised equality and abundance
- the collapse of the communist regime greeted by many as a promise of liberation
- almost everywhere communist regimes gained power through war or revolution
- communist regimes transformed societies
- provided major political/ideological threat to the West
- Cold War between 1946-1991
- scramble for influence in Global South between the U.S and USSR
- a massive nuclear arms race
- then it collapsed
- communism had roots in the 19th-century socialism inspired by Karl Marx
- European socialists believed they could achieve goals through the democratic process
- 20th-century "communists" advocated revolution
- "communism" in Marxist theory is the final stage of historical development
- 1970's: height of communism, almost one-third of the world's population governed by the communist regime
- most important communist societies were USSR and China
- communism arrived in eastern Europe, Mongolia, North Korea, Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia, Cuba, and Afghanistan
- none of these had industrial capitalism that Marx deemed necessary for socialist revolution
- communist parties took root in other areas
- various communist regimes shared common ground
- common ideology, based on Marxism
- inspired by the 1917 Russian Revolution
- during the Cold War, Warsaw Pact created a military alliance of eastern European states and USSR
- council of Mutual Economic Assistance tied eastern European economies to USSR's economy
- 1950: Treaty of Friendship between USSR and China
- relations between communist countries marked by rivalry and hostility
- communist revolutions drew on a mystique of the French Revolution
- ousted aristocracies and old ruling class
- peasant rebellions; educated leadership
- French, Russian, and Chinese revolutions all looked to modernizing future, rid any nostalgia of past
- important differences
- communist revolutions made by organized parties guided by Marxist ideology
- middle classes among victims of communist upheavals, where they were chief beneficiaries of the French Revolution
- communist revolutions carried an explicit message of gender equality
- 1917 Russan Revolution was sudden and explosive
- Tsar Nicholas II was forced to abdicate throne Feb. 1917
- massive social upheaval
- deep-seated social revolution soon showed the inadequacy of Provisional Governments
- wouldn't/couldn't meet the demands of revolutionary masses
- refused to withdraw from WWI
- left opening for rising of radical groups
- the most effective opposition groups were Bolsheviks, led by Vladimir Ulyanov
- Bolsheviks seized power in a coup in October 1917
- claimes to act on behalf of "soviets"
- 3-year civil war followed: Bolsheviks vs a variety of enemies
- 1921: Bolsheviks won
- during the Civil War, Bolsheviks:
- regimented economy
- suppressed nationalist rebellions
- committed atrocities
- integrated lower-class men into the Red Army and local governments
- claimed to defend Russia from imperialists and internal exploiters
- strengthened tendencies toward authoritarianism
- for 25 years, new USSR only communist country
- expansion into eastern Europe because of Soviet occupation at end of WWII
- Stalin sought buffer of "friendly" governments in eastern Europe; imposed communism from outside
- local communist parties had some domestic support
- in Yugoslavia, a communist government emerged with little Soviet help
- 1949: communism won in China
- 1911: Chinese imperial system collapsed
- 1921: Chinese Communist Party (CCP) founded
- CCP grew immensely over the next 25 years and transformed strategy under Mao Zedong
- a formidable enemy in the Guomindang (Kuomintang - Nationalist Party), which ruled China after 1928
- Chiang Kai-shek led Guomindang
- Guomindang promoted modern development in cities
- countryside remained impoverished
- CCP driven from cities developed a new strategy
- looked to peasants for support, not city workers
- gradually won respect and support of peasants
- recruit women made reforms in controlled regions
- outlawed arranged marriages
- made divorce easier
- gave women the right to vote and own property
- women and men receive equal shares during land reform initiatives
- women's associations promoted
- male reactions led to modifications
- given boost by Japan's invasion of China
- reputation for resisting Japanese occupation
- more effective than Guomindang
- CCP addressed both foreign imperialism and peasant exploitation
- expressed Chinese nationalism and demand for social change
- reputation for honesty, unlike Guomindang
- 1920's and 1930's: Joseph Stalin built a socialist society in USSR
- 1950's and 1960's" Mao Zedong did the same in China
- the first step: modernization and industrialization
- a serious attack on class and gender inequalities
- created political systems dominated by the Communist Party
- high ranking party members were expected to exemplify socialism
- other parties are forbidden
- the state controlled almost the entire economy
- China's communist conversion was an easier process than USSR
- USSR paved the way
- Chinese communists won the support of rural masses
- but China had more economic problems to resolve
- pioneered "women's liberation"
- largely directed by state
- USSR almost immediately declared full legal and political equality for women
- divorce, abortion, pregnancy leave, women's work all enabled and encouraged
- 1919: USSR's Communist Party set up Zhenotdel (Women's Department)
- pushed feminist agenda
- male communist officials and ordinary people opposed it
- 1930: Stalin abolished it
- communist China worked for women's equality
- Marriage Law of 1950 ordered free choice of marriage, easier divorce, end of concubines and child marriage, and equal property rights for women
- the CCP implement pro-female changes against strong opposition
- women became more active in the workforce
- limitations on communist women's liberation
- 1930: Stalin declared women's question "solves"
- no direct attack on male domination within family
- women retained burden housework and child care and paid employment
- few women made it into top political leadership
- both China and Russia: communists took the land and redistributed to peasants
- Russia: peasants took and redistributed the land themselves
- China: land and reform team mobilized poor peasants to confront landlords
- second stage rural reform: effort to end private property by collectivizing agriculture
- China: 1950s collectivization largely peaceful and went further than the Soviet Union
- USSR: 1928-1933 collectivization imposed by violence
- industrialization as fundamental
- end humiliating backwardness and property
- create military strength to survive in a hostile world
- Chin followed USSR model
- state ownership of property
- centralized planning (5-7 year plans)
- priority is given to heavy industry
- massive mobilization of resources
- intrusive party control of the whole process
- both experienced major economic growth
- USSR accepted social outcomes of industrialization
- Mao Zedong tried to combat the social effects of industrialization
- Great Leap Forward: 1958-1960
- promoted small-scale industrialization in rural areas
- Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution: mid-1960's
- Cultural Revolution rejected feminism for strikingly masculine gender-neutral model
- confidence in centralized planning
- struggle against nature led to immense environmental damage
- paranoid lifestyle
- fear communists corrupted by bourgeois ideas; became class enemies
- fear of vast conspiracy to restore capitalism
- USSR: The Terror (Great Purge) in the 1930s
- millions of Russians, tens of thousands of communists
- sentenced to harsh labor camps (the gulag)
- 1936-1941: nearly a million people executed
- China: public process
- 1966-1969: Cultural Revolution, escaped the control of communist leadership
- Mao called for rebellion against Communist Party itself
- a purge of millions of alleged capitalist sympathizers
- Mao called in the army to avert civil war
- Terror and Cultural Revolution discredited socialism and contributed to the eventual collapse of the communist experiment
- Europe was the Cold War's first arena
- Soviet concern for security and control in eastern Europe
- American and British - open societies linked to the capitalist world economy
- rival military alliances: NATO and Warsaw Pact
- American sphere of influence: western Europe was voluntary
- Soviet sphere of influence was imposed
- "Iron Curtain" divided 2 spheres
- communism spread into Asia (China, Korea, Vietnam) caused conflict
- North Korea invaded South Korea in 1950
- Vietnam: massive U.S. intervention in the 1960s
- major Cold War-era conflict in Afghanistan
- 1978: Marxist party took over power but alienated population
- 1979-1989: Soviet military intervention led to little success
- 1989: USSR withdrew under international pressure; Afghani communist rule collapsed
- a battle that never happened: Cuba
- 1959: Fidel Castro comes to power
- naturalization of the U.S. assets provoked its hostility
- Castro aligned with USSR
- Cuban Missle Crisis in October 1962
- 1949: USSR nuclear weapon success
- massive arms race; by 1989 world had 60,000 nuclear warheads with complex delivery systems
- 1949-1989: feared massive nuclear destruction and possible human extinction
- both sides aware of destructive power
- careful avoidance of nuclear provocation
- avoidance of direct military confrontation, since it might turn into a nuclear war
- the U.S. and USSR courted third world countries
- the U.S. intervened Iran, the Philippines, Guatemala, El Salvador, Chile, the Congo, and elsewhere where they feared communist penetration
- the U.S. often supported corrupt, authoritarian regimes
- third world countries resisted being used as pawns
- some countries like India claimes "nonalignment" status
- some played superpowers against each other
- the U.S. became the leader of the west against communism
- led to creation of "imperial" presidency
- the power was given to defense and intelligence agencies created "national security state"
- strengthened "military-industrial" complex
- the U.S. military effort sustained by a flourishing economy and increased middle-class society
- the U.S. industry wasn't harmed by WWII unlike other industrial societies
- Americans were "people of plenty"
- the growing pace of the U.S. investment abroad
- American pop culture spread
- jazz, rock-and-roll, rap found foreign audiences
- the 1990s: American movies took 70% European market
- around 33,000 McDonald's restaurants in 119 by 2012
- 1953: Nikita Khrushchev took power in USSR
- 1956: denounced Stalin as criminal
- Cold War justified Soviet emphasis on military and defense industries
- conflicts among communist countries
- Yugoslavia rejected Soviet domination
- 1956: Soviet invasions of Hungary
- 1968: Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia
- early 1980s: Poland threatened with invasion
- brutal suppression tarnished Soviet image, gave credence to western views of cold war (tyranny vs freedom)
- sharp opposition between USSR and China
- 1979: China went to war against communist Vietnam
- late 1970s: Vietnam invaded communist Laos
- 1970s: world communism reached greatest height
- comunist era ended fast and peacefully, 1970s-1991
- 1976: China - Mao Zedong died
- 1989: Europe - popular movements overthrew communist governments
- economic failure of communism
- communist states couldn't catch up economically
- Soviet economy was stagnant
- economic failure limited military capacity
- failures known worldwide
- moral failure of communism
- Stalin's Terror and gulag
- Mao's Cultural Revolution
- near-genocide in Cambodia
- all happened in global climate that embraced democracy and human rights
- 1976: Deng Xiaoping came to power
- relaxed censorship
- released 100,000 political prisoners
- dismantled collectivised farming system
- China: opened to world economy
- result: economic growth and prosperity
- massive corruption among officials, urban inequality, pollution, and coast/interior inequality
- CCP has kept political monopoly
- late 1980s: brutall crashing of democracy
- Tiananmen Square massacre
- China - "strange and troubled hybrid" that combines nationalism, consumerism, and new respect for ancient traditions
- mid-1980s: Mikhail Gorbachev became general secretary
- 1987: launched economic reform program
- openness to greater cultural and intellectual freedoms
- revealed the mess of the USSR: crime, prostitution, suicide, corruption
- extend of Stalin's atrocities incovered
- new religious expression
- ending of government censorship of culture
- 1989: democratization and free elections
- ending of Cold War by making unilateral military cuts, negotiating arms control with the U.S.
- Gorbachev's reforms led to the collapse of USSR
- planned economy dismantled before the market-based system could develop
- new freedoms led to more strident demands
- subordinate states demanded greater autonomy/independence
- Gorbachev refused using force to crush protestors
- eastern European states broke free
- August 1991: conservatives attempted coup
- 15 new and independent states emerged from the breakup of USSR
- 2000: communist world shrunk
- communism lost complete dominance in USSR and eastern Europe
- China mostly abandoned communist economic policies
- Vietnam and Laos remained officially communist - pursued Chinese-style reforms
- the 1990s: Cuba - economic crisis, began to allow small businesses, private food markets, tourism
- North Korea is the most unreformed and Stalinist communist state
- international tensions remain in eastern Asia and the Caribbean
Comments
Post a Comment